Sunday, 19 August 2018

Engine Rebuild (Part 10) - Fitting the Distributor Tower: Aligning the Slotted Head

Refitting the distributor tower is only a small job in the overall engine reassembly, but the steady flow of questions raised on forums shows that it's very easy to get this wrong......
Distributor Tower
It helps to understand how the bits and pieces relate. 

The spindle in the distributor tower rotates the distributor arm which causes a spark to occur at the spark plug of each cylinder in turn. The spindle in the distributor tower has a pinion at the base that is driven by the camshaft. 
The pinion inside this bit.........
.......Needs To Be Correctly Engaged With This Bit.
The camshaft also determines when the engine valves open and close. The camshaft is in turn driven by crankshaft - which controls the movement of the pistons. Through the distributor tower spindle, the camshaft is seeking to manage the correct point for the distributor to make a spark for each cylinder - meaning the spindle needs to rotate the distributor arm to the right position at the right time for the firing sequence in the correct cylinder.

To help ensure this happens, the drive socket on top of the distributor tower spindle has a slot in the top: the slot determines how the distributor is fitted to the spindle in the tower and so influences the point (relative to piston and valve movement and spindle rotation) at which a spark is produced....... 
Drive Socket in the Distributor Tower.
Note that the slot does NOT pass centrally through the axis
The slot in the drive socket seems to be the cause of much confusion and error as the slot does not pass the centre point of the drive head - it is very slightly offset  - giving a 'big half' and a 'small half' - thus when fitting the tower, the alignment of this head socket is crucial for correct ignition timing. 

From background reading, having fitted the distributor tower, any problems typically seem to fall into three scenarios:

1.  The distributor tower has been refitted with the drive socket of the spindle aligned - but the wrong way round (180 degrees out of alignment)
1. Looks okay - but 180 degrees out....
2.  The distributor tower has been refitted without the drive socket of the spindle being orientated in any particular way at all (anything up to 360 degrees out of alignment)
2. No Chance.....
3.  The distributor tower has been refitted with an attempt to align the drive socket, but the drive socket itself is not correctly orientated to the pinion wheel on the other end of the spindle and so will not rest in line with the camshaft. (can be anything up to about 15 degrees out alignment).
3. Nearly - but not parallel.......
Of the above, scenario 1 seems to be the most common and the most likely. It tends to reveal itself only when people come to refit the distributor and set up the timing - by which time the gearbox and clutch housing will have been bolted over the distributor tower - making it impossible to remove and correct properly without stripping the engine down.....However there is a workaround and a fix. The workaround: scenario 1 affects the firing order of the cylinders: rotating the distributor 180 degrees and refitting it restores the correct firing order. The solution also necessitates swapping the long and shot HT leads around a bit. BUT, one issue you might have with a "stacked" (side entry) distributor cap is the matching notches in the distributor and cap: if the distributor is 180 degrees around, then the plug leads will be facing the nose of the car rather than the back! Solution? Fit a 'top exit' distributor cap! The fix: remove the distributor, remove the roll pin holding the drive head on the bottom. Rotate the drive head 180 degrees on the shaft and refit the pin. Firing order will be restored and your plug leads will still point towards the back of the car.
The fix for scenario 1: remove and rotate the drive head of the distributor
The other scenarios should be obvious as soon as you fit the tower, but if you're not paying attention, problems will only come to light when you try to start the car.....

Scenario 3 only really come about if you have stripped the distributor drive tower to replace the oil seal and messed up the reassembly. If you have stripped the distributor drive tower to replace the oil seal, then you will have removed the slotted drive head from the spindle. When reassembling, it is vital that this is correctly oriented on the spindle - to preserve the relationship between the line of the slot and the teeth of the spindle that engage with the camshaft. Mark the drive head and the spindle so that these can be matched up on reassembly.

All three scenarios can come about if you fail to follow the Manuals and check your work.....The correct procedure for refitting the distributor tower correctly is covered by step 35 of Operation DX.100-3 of Manual 518. However the photograph there is not at all helpful and you are better off looking at the equivalent, but updated, photo in Operation D.100-3 of Manual 814 - as it is much clearer and easier to understand the process: it more clearly shows the offset of the drive socket. In BOTH manuals the photos can be misleading as they show the tower bolted home, but also illustrate the two ('before' and 'after') positions of the drive socket.
'a' is orientation before bolting the tower on. 'b' is after it is fitted

STEP ONE
Identifying The Compression Stroke. The first stage of refitting is to find the compression stroke of number one cylinder:  the stroke on which its compressing the air/ fuel mix in the cylinder. Number one cylinder is the one nearest to the gearbox. I used a short length of polythene tubing threaded tightly into the spark plug hole and and a balloon on the end as a 'tell' to show when the piston was compressing: it inflated the balloon.
Tool for Identifying the Compression Stroke. It works with any colour of balloon.
With four of the flywheel bolts loosely fitted to the end of the crankshaft I used a bar to rotate the crank until the balloon inflated. 
Rotating The Crankshaft
Turning the crank a  little more I waited until the balloon was at the point of deflating. In this way I found an approximate position for TDC. 
Compression stroke identified
STEP TWO
Finding TDC (top dead centre). Removing the tube and balloon, I inserted a length of dowel through number one spark plug hole, making a reference mark level with the top of the spark plug 'funnel'. I popped a plastic bottle top with a hole drilled in it over the funnel. This centred the dowel (held it vertical) and accentuated the movement of the dowel and my reference mark.
Using a Dowel to Confirm TDC
Slowly turning the crank back and forth again I was able to find the highest point for the dowel - TDC for that cylinder.

STEP THREE
Aligning and Fitting The Tower. I had rebuilt my distributor tower (see related post from January 2018). Although I had re-orientated the slotted drive socket to the pinion when I refitted it to the spindle, this was a little rough and ready and I wasn't sure it was properly aligned. With TDC of the compression stroke found and set, I did a few dry fits of the distributor tower to check alignment. 

The following instructions assume you are standing on the inlet manifold side of the engine - with the camshaft end sticking out to your left.

Before fitting the spindle in the drive tower, the spindle was rotated so that the slotted head was at an angle of about 45 degrees (bottom left to top right - position 'a' in the photo in manual 814), with the 'small half' of the slotted head (segment 'b' in the photo in Manual 814) closest to the water pump. 
That Diagram Again
Drive Socket Rotated Before Fitting
Keeping the tower in the position it would be when bolted on, I introduced the drive tower 'eye' over the camshaft - stopping short before the pinion on the drive tower spindle engaged the teeth on the camshaft. I loosely fitted the tower bolts to act as alignment guides for subsequent fitting.
Bolts used to Guide the Tower Into Position
The drive tower was then slowly pushed home along the 'guide bolts' - at which point the slotted head rotated clockwise by about 45 degrees as the pinion engaged with the camshaft - leaving it (1) 'horizontal' or in line with the camshaft (back of engine to front of engine) and (2) with the 'small half' of the drive head (segment 'b' in the photo in manual 814) closest to the water pump housing. With the number one cylinder at TDC of it's compression stroke, this is the correct position for the slotted drive head.
With The Tower Pushed Home, The Slotted Head Aligns To The Camshaft
Satisfied with the test fits, I did it for real: I gave a last squirt of oil to the pinion at the bottom of the drive tower and similarly oiled the surface of the camshaft and lubricated the large camshaft oil seal. I fitted a new paper gasket to the back of the drive tower (it came in the Glaser engine gasket set). I reset the spindle so that the slotted head was at 45 degrees and fitted the assembly over the camshaft - stopping short of engaging the pinion. 

I loosely fitted the bolts (smeared with threadlock) and then tightened the bolts up - as you would the wheel nuts of a car. As the pinion engaged the camshaft the slotted head rotated........ ending up in line with the camshaft and 'small half' nearest the water pump.

Job done!

Friday, 17 August 2018

A Quick Word About..........Building an Engine Trolley

I'd done just about as much as I could with my engine on its stand. 

With the time approaching when I would need to re-join the engine and gearbox, I needed to decide what to do. Many people simply stand the engine on it's sump and block it with pieces of wood to stop it falling over.
My engine: split and grounded - 1998
I wasn't keen on that - partly in case it damaged the plate covering the oil filter, partly because I wanted to keep it off the dusty floor, partly because i wanted it at a height i could still work on it and partly because I needed to be able to manoeuvre the engine around a little and from workshop to garage.

A proper Citroen stand ("stand 3083-T") is shown on several photos in the Manuals.......
Citroen engine stand
.........and you can also make a sledge on wheels to mate the gearbox to the engine (tool MR.630-42/13).


I made enquiries through the DS Yahoo group to see if anyone had tried to make anything similar for engine and gearbox and got lucky: someone replied to say his brother had built a stand. I pressed them for details and he provided a couple of photos. It looked great! Just what I had in mind! They dug around a little more and even came up with a build plan for it - including all the crucial measurements 

I'm not a welder and so adapted the plans to enable me to build something from wood - 75cm x 75cm fence posts to be exact. I'd already built a basic trolley using a small pallet and some castor wheels. I used that as my base. I used the sturdy fence posts to make the supports under the engine mounts and screwed them to two long 'rails'. It came out looking like this.....
One foot pad has an overhang to leave room for the exhaust downpipes
As ever with these things - copy at your own risk, and put safety first.

I was conscious that the two upright arms may fold in (or out!) under the weight of the engine - so needed to brace them. As well as the main, long, hex headed screws going up through the rails and into the arms, I added some short straps to the outer joins, and used some metal tubing (metal channelling used to protect electrical cabling) to join the two rails - with the bonus that the stand's width could then be adjusted.


Wood was convenient to work with, but a lot chunkier than the steel used in the original design I was shown. I knew at some point I would want to fit the exhaust downpipe, so topped my upright arms with some offcuts of sturdy angle to create a short overhang - just enough to leave me some space on the exhaust side.

Strapping the engine onto the crane to take the weight, I gingerly released it from the stand....
Freed from the engine stand
.....and slowly lowered it onto its new home. And here's what the stand looks like with the engine perched on it.....

Now where did I put that gearbox?

Monday, 6 August 2018

Engine Rebuild (Part 9) - Gearbox, Differential and Bell Housing

As you might expect, before you can rebuild the engine, the gearbox needs to be split from it. As the engine rebuild neared completion, I began to think about the gearbox: with the engine now looking much cleaner, the gearbox was begging for attention. I had already given it a wash with white spirit and a pressure wash (yes -  the dreaded pressure wash!) back in 2015. 
Initial clean up - 7 June 2015
As a result, the main gearbox body didn’t look too bad – shiny even – but the top plate and the bellhousing still looked dull and dirty.
Gearboxes compared - July 2018
The gearbox I planned to use was untested before the car was taken off the road - so something of an unknown quantity in terms of wear and tear. A line of argument said I should fix EVERYTHING while I could – to remove any uncertainty. I could see that argument, but firstly it would have involved high cost for new bearings and a re-manufactured crown wheel and pinion amongst other things. Secondly I didn't have the tools or confidence to do it myself and lastly I didn’t have the money to pay someone else to do the work for me.

The process for stripping and rebuilding a gearbox is covered in Operation D.330-3 in section 2 of volume 2 of Manual 814. Overall, Operation 330-3 is LONG and complicated.....which is partly why I didn't want to dig too deep into my gearbox. So deep that I couldn't get out. Reminding myself that I wasn’t out to build a Grand Prix winner, I stuck to my plan of just removing the bell housing and cleaning the gearbox - though even that necessitated some disassembly.

After removing the clutch operating components – thrust bearing, operating fork and clutch cylinder - the first big job was to remove the two shaft housings that connect to the differential. This was just tedious due to the large number of bolts hidden away around their circumferences.
Removing the Differential Shaft Housings
The shafts are oiled by the gearbox oil entering the housings - and so the housings are a close fit to the gearbox. 
Differential shaft removed
Behind each shaft housing is a paper sealing gasket. Replacements for these are available from the usual suppliers.
Example of shaft housing and gasket
As the shaft housings were removed from each side, a large distance piece with a bevelled edge and another large shim dropped out of the aperture of the gearbox body.
Differential, housings and and their big distance spacer rings......
It is possible to press out and replace the bearings in the differential shafts – but again I had no plan (or ambition) to do full rebuilds and, if I had, it would have meant further work setting up the gearbox at rebuild time.
shafts are 'handed'
Standing the housings on their wheel stud ends like stilts, and with the inner bearings protected with rags (so that liquid did not go into them) - I gave the housings a good wash and stipple in Jizer, followed by a rinse and blow dry. They came out looking a lot better than before.

Removing the Bellhousing
With the shafts and housings removed, the bellhousing can be split from the gearbox. When assembled at the factory, Citroen fitted ‘tamper-proof’ bolts in a couple of places. Not sure why they placed them here though? These are ‘tamper-proof’ in that the heads are an unusual design and so they are difficult to remove!
Special-headed Citroen Set Screw
By chance I already had a special shock absorber socket  - just a cheap Ebay thing - and found that, with a gentle tap from a hammer, it gave a snug fit on these weird bolts. It's OEM tool number 25284 if you're interested.
This tool just about fitted the special set screws
I worked around the bellhousing until the last bolt was free and.....


.....with a tug, the bellhousing broke free of it’s mastic seal…..spilling the heavy crown wheel onto my workbench (that was a surprise!).....

.......and revealing the drive pinion behind.
Gearbox Input shaft and drive pinion
Now I could get the bellhousing cleaned.


Cleaning the Gearbox Top Cover
With the differential shaft housings, bellhousing and crown wheel removed, the gearbox was a lot lighter. I took the opportunity to pour some white spirit in the filler hole and slooshed it about to dilute and release any lumpy crud stuck in it’s dark corners. I didn’t want to be too thorough as I didn’t want to leave the gearbox completely free of a protective oil layer.

I also wanted to take the top cover off the gearbox. Mostly so that I could see what state it was in inside (I was worried that my pressure washing of two years earlier might have left me with a rusting gearbox full of water), but also because I wanted to get the top cover vapour blasted.

The hydraulic box lid has five hydraulic pistons set into it for the four forward gears and reverse. These can be removed, but I didn’t have a tool for compressing the springs and didn’t fully understand the instructions for the ‘work-around’. If in doubt, don't fiddle.......
Inside a BVH gearbox lid
I worked out that, with the clutch lock removed, the gearbox lid could be removed without tampering with these and so, more importantly, it could be replaced without the need to reset or recalibrate anything.
Lid removed - no rust
The hydraulic gear pistons operate the dogs on the shafts
Happy that the gearbox was not rusty and full of water, my attention turned to getting the lid vapour blasted. I didn’t want to remove the gear-operating pistons, but neither did I want vapour-blasting medium in them. I took a chance. I decided to box-off the pistons to protect them: I replaced the cluster of five hydraulic pipes back on the pistons connections – and then blanked off the union where all the pipe ends meet. I then made a template from a piece of think polythene (a breadboard) and, with RTV silicone sump sealant, blanked off the open side of the cover by bolting this onto the gearbox cover. 
'Blanking Plate' for vapour blasting gearbox cover
I was fairly confident that this 'sandwich' would be water tight, so sent it off for vapour blasting. The worst case scenario was that I would need to find a way to strip and clean the pistons after all. 

The result of the vapour blasting was very pleasing – much cleaner than it had been. Like new in fact! Removing the polythene plate I was also pleased to find it dry inside. The hydraulic pipes were undone. I used a vacuum cleaner to make sure any stray beads of media were pulled away from the apertures and not pushed into them.

Fitting the top cover back on the gearbox was the reversal of removal, using a thin bead of RTV sump sealant.


Re-assembling the Differential Shaft Housings and Bell Housing
After vapour blasting, the bell housing (or as Citroen call it, the 'Clutch Housing') looked great! I was looking forward to refitting it to the gearbox – only I didn’t have enough hands….… and few chances to take photos.

The process I followed for putting all of this back together is covered at step 35 of Operation D.330-3 in section 2 of volume 2 of Manual 814. I reasoned that as I had not rebuilt the differential shafts, nor anything in the gearbox, I would proceed on the working assumption that everything would/ should fit back together just as it came apart... ..seemed reasonable to me

The aim therefore was to correctly locate the crown wheel on the pinion, as well as locating the differential shaft distance pieces in the circular hole formed by joining the bell housing and gearbox. As an added complication, before bolting up the bell housing, I also needed to make sure that the machined surfaces on the sides of these two joined pieces were aligned - to provide a flat surface for the paper gaskets of the differential shaft housings.  To achieve this, the gearbox/ bell housing combo needed to be partly assembled and then one of the housings loosely bolted in place to align it’s two half surfaces. Easy!

Except gravity kept getting in the way: The crown wheel frequently rolled out of the open end - making it impossible to accurately introduce and set the bell housing. As added complications, the bearing distance pieces and shims/ rings needed to be located before the bell housing/ gearbox combo could be fully tightened up. Those distance pieces were buggers and popped out at the drop of a hat! Citroen have special clamping tools for holding the crown wheel in place while the bell housing is loosely attached. The design can be found in volume 2 of Manual 814. Two pieces are needed - each of a different depth - 'a' in the diagram
Citroen tool for holding the differential in the gearbox
The tools are really little more than bent pieces of bar, but serve to act as an extra pair of hands. With the bell housing loosely fitted over the crown wheel, the tools can then be removed, and the distance pieces can be fitted. 
Citroen tool in place
I probably could have made a pair of tools but, keen to press on, I roped-in my wife Gayle instead. With the crown wheel and spacers located, I attempted to hold these in place with a big wire loop around the gearbox. What a bodge! This was far from ideal and it was really Gayle that held it together – literally.
Crown and pinion wired in place - badly......
I cut the wire, slipped on the distance pieces (in the correct order) and Gayle held them in place. There were no second chances with this as the bellhousing/ gearbox join already had a bead of  sticky RTV gasket sealant on it’s surface and so wouldn’t have liked to have been moved about.

The bell housing was slid over the long bolts on each side while Gayle held the crown wheel and spacers in place. When it finally came together, it seemed to just slot into place. I had to be careful that the distance pieces did not pop out of their spaces but once the bellhousing and gearbox was joined, they seemed content to stay in place.
Bolting on the differential bearing housings
There is an odd mix of M7s and M8s (and of differing lengths), used to secure the bellhousing so I had already laid out all the bolts according to the positions they fitted.

With the bellhousing loosely bolted together I fitted the right hand shaft housing (the one with the shorter shaft) and it’s paper gasket. Once that had pulled the machined surfaces flat and level, I tightened up the bellhousing to gearbox bolts properly and removed the differential shaft housings again. 

I checked that the two housing half surfaces were still level. Satisfied, I gave the paper gaskets of the housings a smear of ‘Hylomar blue’ just to make sure they sealed well and then stuck them to the housings. (You need to make sure you get them the right way round and line up all the bolt holes). I tightened the housings up.
Bolts on differential shaft housings
Not bad. Looks a lot better.
Compare and contrast....